level 1
贴吧用户_595PWKt
楼主
JCRQ2中科院Q4的期刊官方平均审稿52天,我的用了100多天,经历一次催稿最终拒稿重投。Thank you for submitting your manuscript to World Neurosurgery. I regret to inform you that your paper is not acceptable for publication in it's current form. We have completed the review of your manuscript and a summary of the Editor's Decision to 'Reject - Invite to Resubmit' is appended below. For your information and guidance, any specific comments explaining why I have reached this decision and those received from reviewers, if available, are listed at the end of this letter.We feel that the manuscript truly has merit. You have the option of resubmitting a substantially revised version of your paper, which would be considered as a new submission. If you decide to do this, you should refer to the reference number of the current paper in your cover letter and include a separate file with 'Response to Reviewer Comments' which explains in detail how the paper has been changed or not, in reply to the Editor and Reviewer comments. In addition, please select the appropriate article type that starts with the word Resubmission (i.e., Resubmission Original Article; Resubmission Literature Review; etc).Thank you for giving us the opportunity to consider your work.Kind regards这里是EIC的评论。很奇怪的是决定信里没贴全审稿人的评论,只有Reviewer2的一小部分评论,说方法学有问题,Reviewer1和3根本没有,通讯正写信argue。而且我是一作网站上是直接Rej,什么别的都没有,通讯收到的邮件是Reject - Invite to Resubmit。这是怎么回事?这篇文章还有希望吗?

2025年07月16日 16点07分
1
