公司欠我工资，股东承诺代替公司给两台机器作为赔偿，后来才知道实物代替工资是违法的，于是我发起劳动仲裁想追回工资。
问法援实物代替工资是不是违法，问十个有八个说不违法，现在我也不清楚到底是不是违法，还是我们本地不违法

口头无效吧，如果和你签协议有公司公章应该没问题

快进到法援自创法律

主要是我已经签了补偿协议，估计很难追回钱了

亲测法律援助不靠谱 我去北京监察大队找的法律援助 我问点问题在手机上查这查那 打电话这问那问 最后还给我说不确定 真心话 还没我懂得多

花一万多找的律师都是两头吃，还免费的坑你

https://kmd2hx.smartapps.cn/pages/lawArticle/index?id=840035&oauthType=search&searchParams=%7B%22failUrl%22%3A%22https%3A%2F%2Fm.findlaw.cn%2Flawyers%2Farticle%2Fd840035.html%22%2C%22logParams%22%3A%22pu%3D%24pu%26baiduid%3D%24baiduid%26tcreq4log%3D1%26isAtom%3D1%26cyc%3D1%26clk_info%3D%7B%5C%22tplname%5C%22%3A%5C%22www_normal%5C%22%2C%5C%22srcid%5C%22%3A1599%2C%5C%22ivkStatus%5C%22%3A%5C%22new_ivk_success%5C%22%2C%5C%22type%5C%22%3A%5C%22xcx%5C%22%2C%5C%22naType%5C%22%3A%5C%22%5C%22%2C%5C%22ivkSource%5C%22%3A%5C%22h5_schema%5C%22%2C%5C%22jumpType%5C%22%3A%5C%22xcx%5C%22%2C%5C%22jumpId%5C%22%3A110%2C%5C%22xcx_path%5C%22%3A%5C%22%25252Fpages%25252FlawArticle%25252Findex%25253Fid%25253D840035%5C%22%2C%5C%22xcx_id%5C%22%3A%5C%22jNGgkUG5eKsMRyMNDYkj28oWAEmquMja%5C%22%2C%5C%22xcx_from%5C%22%3A%5C%221081000810003000%5C%22%7D%26lid%3D735
13214204225
73102%26l%3D1%26t%3Diphone%26ref%3Dwww_iphone%26from%3D1013966u%26order%3D4%26w%3D0_10_%E8%AE%A9%E4%B8%8E%E6%8B%85%E4%BF%9D%E4%B8%8E%E5%AE%9E%E7%89%A9%E6%8A%B5%E5%80%BA%26tj%3Dwww_normal_4_0_10_l%26src%3Dhttps%25253A%25252F%25252Fm.findlaw.cn%25252Flawyers%25252Farticle%25252Fd840035.html%22%7D&useTpl=1&_swebfr=1&_swebFromHost=vivobrowser&bdswankey=vivobrowser%3A%2F%2Fswan%2FjNGgkUG5eKsMRyMNDYkj28oWAEmquMja%2Fpages%2FlawArticle%2Findex%3Fid%3D840035%26oauthType%3Dsearch%26searchParams%3D%257B%2522failUrl%2522%253A%2522https%253A%252F%252Fm.findlaw.cn%252Flawyers%252Farticle%252Fd840035.html%2522%252C%2522logParams%2522%253A%2522pu%253D%2524pu%2526baiduid%253D%2524baiduid%2526tcreq4log%253D1%2526isAtom%253D1%2526cyc%253D1%2526clk_info%253D%257B%255C%2522tplname%255C%2522%253A%255C%2522www_normal%255C%2522%252C%255C%2522srcid%255C%2522%253A1599%252C%255C%2522ivkStatus%255C%2522%253A%255C%2522new_ivk_success%255C%2522%252C%255C%2522type%255C%2522%253A%255C%2522xcx%255C%2522%252C%255C%2522naType%255C%2522%253A%255C%2522%255C%2522%252C%255C%2522ivkSource%255C%2522%253A%255C%2522h5_schema%255C%2522%252C%255C%2522jumpType%255C%2522%253A

以物抵债（未发工资已经形成）不违法。债务未发生之前（如明年的工资）就约定以物抵债属于让与担保，不清偿型的直接让与担保是违法的。

用实物代替工资，只能说不合法，算不上违法，不合法并不必然违法，但违法必然不合法，如果两台机器价值比你的工资更高，为什么不要呢？