如题，最新一期坦克装甲车辆介绍了美国坦克发展史，写得确实不错，可是有一些地方感觉值得商讨，比如M26潘兴的那一部分

首先关于它对抗虎式表现不佳，首先我上一些外网资料，这是美军各型火炮的穿甲厚度的数据

从上面可以看出90毫米火炮即使使用穿甲能力最差的M82弹也可以远距离击穿虎式炮盾。90mm火炮的穿透力（HVAP为2000米154mm30度，而D-25T只有五百米160mm垂直穿深）完全可击穿二战中除IS-3 110首上部分外的所有坦克,另据南斯拉夫的测试,90mm火炮和KWK43火炮分别可在800m与750m击穿T-55的炮塔正面因此应能击穿IS-3。

太平洋战场方面，美方纪录要到1945年4月的冲绳战役中才参战，但是日本军方则指出在1945年2月的硫磺岛战役美国海军陆战队就已运用此型坦克[1]；M-26带来的性能优势相当显著，日军评估后推测这种坦克正面装甲有150毫米、侧面有76毫米厚，在冲绳战役也显示一式反坦克炮在隐蔽阵地对M-26采极近距离射击仍然没用，如果是过去的M4中坦克运用此战术还可勉强击毁，可说日军前线单位几乎不存在任何击溃M-26的手段。

关于其威力不如英制17磅，这得看是哪一种炮弹

同一时期的虎式和虎王主炮的穿甲威力

关于IS-2主炮和美制90毫米火炮的对比

那个虎式打潘兴仅仅是击伤的照片

On 6 March, just after the 3rd Armor Division had entered the city of Cologne, a famous tank duel took place. A Panther tank on the street in the front of Cologne Cathedral was laying in wait for enemy tanks. Two M4A4 Sherman were supporting infantry and came up on the same street as the Panther. They ended up stopping just before the Cathedral because of rubble in the street and didn't see the enemy Panther. The lead Sherman was knocked out, killing 3 of the 5 crew. A T26E3 was in the next street over and was called over to engage the Panther. What happened next was described by the T26E3 gunner Cpl. Clarence Smoyer: "We were told to just move into the intersection far enough to fire into the side of the enemy tank, which had its gun facing up the other street (where the Sherman had been destroyed). However, as we entered the intersection, our driver had his periscope turned toward the Panther and saw their gun turning to meet us. When I turned our turret, I was looking into the Panther's gun tube; so instead of stopping and becoming an easy target, our driver kept going through the intersection, so I fired a round and hit the enemy tank. The Panther was dispatched and burned for 3 days after the duel, with 2 of the crew surviving."[44] The action was recorded by a Signal Corps cameraman Tec.Sgt Jim Bates.（这是M26潘兴击毁一辆黑豹的详细战例）

这是潘兴近距离仅仅被虎式击伤的详细记录
After training the tank crews, the T26E3 tanks were first committed to combat on 25 February, with the 3rd Armored Division, in the fighting for the Roer River. On 26 February, a T26E3 named Fireball was knocked out in an ambush at Elsdorf while overwatching a roadblock. Silhouetted by a nearby fire, the Pershing was in a disadvantageous position. A concealed Tiger tank fired three shots from about 100 yd (91 m). The first penetrated the turret through the machine gun port in the mantlet, killing both the gunner and the loader. The second shot hit the gun barrel, causing the round that was in the chamber to fire with the effect of distorting the barrel. The last shot glanced off the turret side, taking off the upper cupola hatch. While backing up to escape, the Tiger became entangled in debris and was abandoned by the crew.[40] Fireball was quickly repaired and returned to service on 7 March.[41]

Shortly afterward, also at Elsdorf, another T26E3 knocked out a Tiger I and two Panzer IVs.[42] The Tiger was knocked out at 900 yd (820 m) with the 90-mm HVAP T30E16 ammunition.[38] Photographs of this knocked out Tiger I in Hunnicutt's book showed a penetration through the front gun mantlet.[43] （另一个击毁战例）

对比前几天我发的那个IS-2在多少距离能击穿虎王正面的贴，大家可以看到IS-2在600米就能击穿虎王首上，而M26潘兴曾被虎式近距离多发命中却只是被击伤的战例（虎式的88炮比IS-2的122炮要强，当然不排除个例的影响），由此可见M26潘兴的装甲防护力优于虎式，和虎王持平。

渣翻译：
在3月6日，就在第3装甲师进入科隆市之时，发生了一场有名的坦克对决。一辆豹式坦克当时正蹲守在科隆教堂前等待敌军坦克到来。此时两辆负责支援步兵的M4A4谢尔曼进入了豹式所在的街道。因为街道上废墟瓦砾的阻挡使得它们停止了前进，并且没有发现敌方的豹式。豹式干掉了领头的谢尔曼，杀死了5名车组中的3个。隔壁街道的一辆T26E3被命令去干掉豹式。炮手卡拉伦斯·斯莫伊尔下士讲述了后面发生故事，他描述道：“我们被告知进入街口，在足够近的距离朝那个火炮正指向另一条街（谢尔曼被摧毁的那里）的敌方坦克侧面开火。不过就在我们走到街口时，我们的驾驶员就从潜望镜看到豹式的炮塔正转过来捕捉我们。当我把炮塔转过来以后，我正好看到了豹式黑的炮口。为了不那么容易被锁定，我们的驾驶员没有停车而是继续开过街口，而我则打了一发炮弹并击中了敌方坦克。那个豹式就这样被做掉了，并一直烧了3天，他们只有两个人幸存。”那次行动被军方摄影师吉姆·贝特斯技术中士记录了下来。

被潘兴干掉的黑豹

楼主讲的好用心_(:3 」∠)_我来捧个场

←_←

我更喜欢集结=，=