凉粉上传了NS的不少英文歌到youtube上，引来了不少中外人士的留言。这些留言无疑值得分析和反省。应玉米地拓荒者的请求，今天首先关注一下近期NS唱得比较多的歌曲《walk away》首先分析这个视频下的19个留言http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wgb_bSgKxko

作者： 茶杯的死期 2007-2-4 11:13 　 回复此发言 -----------------当了吧主，派头是不一样啊！

首先声明，我的工作和台湾李神探的工作是一样的，并不想下什么结论，我只负责找出事实！我想找的事实很简单，就是有多少真正的外国人留言，留言内容如何。

第一条 jR0CK (4 days ago)she learned the american accent by thinking she's the original singer and portrays their voice at the beginning. she got this blackness in her when she sings =) talented. 从留言人网站找到的玉照。无疑是海外留学生

第二条 ncblazin247 (6 days ago)wow she sounds exactly like the song, and shes hotAge: 23 身份不明

第三条 transparent91 (2 weeks ago)OUCH!! That's the hottest i've seen in a long time!Country: Norway ，挪威人，找到留言人玉照，确实是洋人，还是男的！！

第四条 marcolun3 (2 months ago)yes, the same girl Age: 30Country: Belize （洪都拉斯首都）从他上传的全部是NS的视频来看，应该是旅居洪都拉斯的LF!

第五条 NZCherub (2 months ago)Does anyone know if this is the same girl as the one in the video called 'Taiwan Girl Singing' or something like that. She is singing 'Loving You (is easy cos your beautiful)' by Minnie Riperton???Age: 23Country: New Zealand 查过了，留言者来自新西兰，这是他玉照！

第六条 wind
lz
x (2 months ago)Jane is a very deligent girl with an amazing vocal cord. She can sing at least in mandarin, cantonese, english, spanish and korean. She can sing at least as good as Mariah Carey, Shania Twain, Tina Turner, Madona, Christina, Nora Jones or Kelly. She is genius in perfect control of all different kind of music, from the most traditional chinese folk songs to the most complicated english songs. No other singer in the whole world is as talented in so many ways as she is. Hometown: shenyangCountry: ChinaOccupation: teacher 这个毫无疑问是LF啦！

第七条 cheb07 (3 months ago)better than kelly Age: 18Country: Canada 从她上传视频找到的，很可能是她的玉照！

哈哈，洁宝，你红了。。。。。。作者： 玉米地拓荒者 2007-2-4 11:47 　 回复此发言 -----------------只要敢于开拓，不落俗套，自然会红啦！

第八条 xymex (3 months ago)actually..she really just learned eng from listening to music...*sigh* smart ppl.. Name: twilightAge: 19 从留言语气看，显然不是外国人，而是知情粉丝。从档案看好象还是哈韩的！

第九条 purpleducksxing (3 months ago)Oooh....chinese eh?Age: 15Country: United States 应该是美国人，照片上三者之一

第十条 Drownedworld (3 months ago)Did she grow up or spend some time in the West? Her grasp of the English language (at least in this song anyway) is unbelieveable. I don't believe that she can sing English this good just by listening to the songs and memorizing them. Name: Pei PeiAge: 19 身份不明。也许从他的名字透露了什么？

第十一，十二条是对第十条留言的回答，显然是粉丝的留言xymex (3 months ago)actually..she really just learned eng from listening to music...*sigh* smart ppl..jR0CK (4 days ago)she learned the american accent by thinking she's the original singer and portrays their voice at the beginning. she got this blackness in her when she sings =) talented.

第十三条 skitty770 (4 months ago)wow she sings good! Name: gracieAge: 26Country: United States 从她favorite的视频来看，她对杨丞琳和周杰伦都有好感，可能有亚洲背景？

第十四条 Laura1115 (4 months ago)Good Voice!! Kelly would be proud! Age: 28Country: United States 这个很可能是留言者的玉照！还是男的噢！

第十五条 XtinaLover (5 months ago)overall not good but she has a good voice though. Age: 26 身份不明，但是她明显是KC，P!nk的粉丝

第十六条 kellyclarksonfan4e (5 months ago)way to go Age: 24Country: United States 显然是KC的狂热粉丝，favorite中KC的视频铺天盖地！

第十七条 kellyclarksonfan4e (5 months ago)k i'm a major kelly fan since 2002 and dang that was good you like really study kelly i can tell your a fan to.good job kelly would be proud of you and i also like how they kept kelly vocals to. 和第十六条的留言者是同一个人