来一道逻辑题,为增加难度请用英文回答哦!欢迎讨论!
macbook吧
全部回复
仅看楼主
level 7
lobster0616 楼主
Nathan, Joshua, Michelle, and Denise were in a room where a porcelain vase was found broken. When an inquiry was conducted by the building caretaker, each made a statement.
Nathan: Denise broke the vase.
Joshua: Michelle did it.
Michelle: I did not do it.
Denise: Joshua lied when he said Michelle did it.
The caretaker knew that only two statements were true and concluded that Denise broke the vase.
Describe in complete sentences the method you use to show that the caretaker made an incorrect conclusion.
2012年04月28日 16点04分 1
level 7
lobster0616 楼主
没人啊!mb吧午夜档肯定有英语帝啊!
2012年04月28日 16点04分 2
level 11
2012年04月28日 16点04分 3
level 10
names are represent by initial letters。and 0 is for true 1 is for false。statements can be Simplified in this way and results can be
1:N 0J 0M 1D 1
2:N 0J 1M 0D 1
3:N 0J 1M 1D 0
4:N 1J 1M 0D 0
5:N 1J 0M 1D 0
6:N 1J 0M 0D 1
===and so much for today,i got something else to do....
2012年04月28日 17点04分 5
level 7
There is a contradiction between Nathan's and Michelle's statements. So one of them must be lying. Therefore, Joshua is telling the truth and Nathan broke the vase.
2012年04月28日 17点04分 6
level 7
lobster0616 楼主
回复5楼:没看懂你用的什么方法。这是我一高一学弟的作业。他不会。没想到把我也难住了
2012年04月28日 18点04分 7
level 17
姿势帖。。
2012年04月28日 23点04分 8
level 5
there were two ture compatible statement。 let's look at the first statement, witch was "D broke the vase". certainly the J's statement can't be the second right atatement, because it oppose “N”. and then, the two statement left seems compatible logicaly,so we think about it later.
the second statement can't be true while other three opion were not supprt it. so~we got the liar(J said M did it, so M is't compatible. N had the different judgement, D? let's just forget about it……)
2012年04月29日 02点04分 9
level 12
LSSB
2012年04月29日 03点04分 12
level 7
lobster0616 楼主
这个解法似乎是对的
2012年04月29日 03点04分 13
level 10
just a simple contradiction between the statements and the caretaker's conclusion…
2012年04月29日 03点04分 14
level 9
[晕][晕][晕]

2012年04月29日 05点04分 15
level 9
英语秀啊
2012年04月29日 05点04分 16
1